Register
Strategy guide

Understand a Long Call Butterfly Spread

A long call butterfly is a three-strike options strategy for a market you expect to finish near a level. You buy one call below the target, sell two calls at the target and buy one call above it. The cost is small, the loss is limited to that cost, and the profit is largest if the index expires exactly at the middle strike.

QuantPower Research · Updated 14 Nov 2026 · 17 min read

The butterfly is a trade on where the index will be, not on which way it will go. It suits a quiet expiry, a level the market keeps returning to, or a view that implied volatility is too high for the days left. This guide explains how a butterfly spread works on Nifty, the numbers on one lot, how to choose the width and the middle strike, how it behaves before expiry, what it costs to trade, and how to build, test and run it as an algo.

At a glance

Long call butterfly
Market viewThe index ends near a specific level at expiry
LegsBuy 1 lower call, sell 2 middle calls, buy 1 higher call, same expiry, equal gaps
CostA small net debit
Maximum profitThe gap between strikes minus the debit, at the middle strike
Maximum lossThe debit
BreakevensLower strike plus the debit, and higher strike minus the debit
Time decayHelps near the middle strike, mostly in the last days
VolatilityA fall in IV helps

A short history of the butterfly spread

The butterfly is as old as listed options. When the Chicago Board Options Exchange opened on 26 April 1973 with standard strikes and expiries, traders could for the first time buy and sell options at several strikes of the same expiry and combine them into fixed shapes.2 The same year, Fischer Black and Myron Scholes published the pricing model that let traders value each leg and see why the middle of a butterfly gains as expiry nears.1

Floor traders used butterflies to price the curve of option values across strikes and to hedge positions that would lose if the market stopped at one price. The name, and the four-leg structure, were standard in the trading books by 1980, when Lawrence McMillan's *Options as a Strategic Investment* set out the butterfly beside the other spreads.7 Sheldon Natenberg's *Option Volatility and Pricing* later showed how a butterfly's value depends on volatility and on time left, which is why it is cheap far from expiry and comes alive in the last days.8

In India, index options began on the NSE in June 2001 with monthly expiries. Weekly options on Bank Nifty and then Nifty made the butterfly a short-dated trade: a structure that once needed weeks to pay could now be set up a few days before a weekly expiry. Since 20 November 2024 each exchange lists one weekly index expiry, so a Nifty butterfly on the NSE now expires on Tuesday, and a Sensex butterfly on the BSE on Thursday.45

How a butterfly spread works

The two short calls at the middle strike earn the most when the index pins that strike. The two long calls on either side limit the risk in both directions. The trade is cheap because the middle calls pay for most of the outer ones.

A butterfly is a precise bet. It pays well in a narrow range and loses its small debit outside it. You can build the same shape with puts, or as an iron fly strategy, which collects a credit instead of paying a debit.

Think of the butterfly as two spreads joined at the middle strike. The lower half is a bull call spread: buy the 24,800 call, sell the 25,000 call. The upper half is a bear call spread: sell the 25,000 call, buy the 25,200 call. Below 24,800 both halves are worth nothing. Between 24,800 and 25,000 the bull half gains while the bear half is still worthless. Above 25,000 the bear half starts to give back what the bull half earned, and above 25,200 the two cancel completely. That is why the payoff rises to a peak at the middle strike and falls back on both sides.

The numbers on one lot

Using Black–Scholes model prices with Nifty at 25,000, 12 days to expiry, IV of 14%, a 6.5% interest rate and a lot of 65:9

  • Buy the 24,800 call at ₹398.30
  • Sell two 25,000 calls at ₹280.48 each
  • Buy the 25,200 call at ₹187.48
  • Net debit: ₹24.82 per unit, or ₹1,613 per lot
Nifty at expiryP&L per lot
24,800 or lower−₹1,613
24,825breakeven
24,900+₹4,887
25,000+₹11,387
25,100+₹4,887
25,175breakeven
25,200 or higher−₹1,613

The best case pays about seven times the cost. In the model, the chance that Nifty finishes between the two breakevens is about 22%. A butterfly loses more often than it wins, and the wins are usually less than the maximum.

Long call butterfly payoff at expiry: 24,800, 25,000 and 25,200 calls; breakevens 24,824.82 and 25,175.18, maximum profit ₹175.18 and maximum loss ₹24.82 per unit (numbers from the example above)
Long call butterfly payoff

Interactive payoff chart: change the spot, IV, lot size and days to expiry to see the curve, breakevens and Greeks.

Call butterfly or put butterfly

The same three strikes can be built with puts: buy the 24,800 put, sell two 25,000 puts and buy the 25,200 put. In the model the puts cost ₹145.36, ₹227.11 and ₹333.68, so the put butterfly costs ₹24.82 per unit, the same as the call butterfly. That is not a coincidence. Put-call parity ties each call to the put at the same strike, and in a butterfly the differences cancel because the strikes are equally spaced.

In practice, choose the side with the better quotes. Out-of-the-money options usually trade with tighter spreads than deep in-the-money ones. For a butterfly centred at the money, that means the lower wing is cheaper to trade in puts and the upper wing in calls. A butterfly built from both, with a put spread below and a call spread above, is the iron fly.

Choosing the width

WingsDebit per lotMaximum profit per lotProfit range at expiryChance of profit (model)
100 points₹406₹6,09424,906 to 25,094about 12%
200 points₹1,613₹11,38724,825 to 25,175about 22%
300 points₹3,594₹15,90624,755 to 25,245about 30%

Wider wings cost more and pay more, and the profit range is wider. Narrow wings are cheap lottery tickets on a pin.

A useful way to choose is to compare the width with the move you expect to the expiry. A rough expected move is the price of the at-the-money straddle: here the 25,000 call and put together cost about ₹508, so the market is pricing a move of roughly 500 points either way over 12 days. A 200-point butterfly needs Nifty to finish inside a band far narrower than that. That is the trade: you are saying the market will be quieter than the options price suggests.

The middle strike

Most traders centre the butterfly at the money, or at a level the index is likely to gravitate to, such as the strike with the highest open interest or the max pain level near expiry. A butterfly centred away from the money is a cheap directional trade: one centred at 25,200 profits only if Nifty rises to around that level.

Three centring rules are common:

  1. At the money at entry. Simple and neutral. The algo picks the strike nearest the index when it enters.
  2. The highest open interest strike. Large open interest at a strike can act as a magnet near expiry, though not always.
  3. The [max pain meaning](/max-pain-meaning) level. The strike at which option buyers as a whole would lose the most. It moves through the week and is a guide, not a forecast.

Whichever rule you use, keep it fixed when you test. A rule that changes from week to week cannot be tested.

Bank Nifty

Bank Nifty options expire monthly. With Bank Nifty at 55,000, 15 days to expiry, IV of 15% and a lot of 30, a 500-point butterfly (buy 54,500, sell two 55,000, buy 55,500 calls) costs about ₹58.88 per unit, or ₹1,766 per lot. The maximum profit is about ₹13,234 per lot, and the breakevens are 54,559 and 55,441. The shape is the same; the wider strikes match Bank Nifty's larger moves.

Weekly or monthly expiry

A butterfly on a weekly Nifty expiry is a short trade. Entered two to four days before Tuesday's expiry, it spends most of its life in the period when its value rises fastest. A butterfly on a monthly expiry, entered three weeks out, costs about the same but changes value slowly for the first two weeks and needs the index to stay near the middle for much longer.

Weekly (Nifty, Tuesday)Monthly (Nifty or Bank Nifty)
Days held2 to 510 to 20
Value change per day early onModerateSlow
Risk of a large move before expiryLowerHigher
Orders per monthUp to 24 (6 per week)6
FitsA quiet week, a known levelA slow, range-bound month

How a butterfly behaves before expiry

At entry the 200-point butterfly has almost no delta, a theta of about +₹67 a day per lot and a vega of about −₹113 per lot for each 1-point rise in IV. Its value grows slowly at first and quickly at the end.

With Nifty unchanged at 25,000, the model shows these profits per lot as expiry nears:

Days leftButterfly value per unitProfit per lot
12 (entry)₹24.82₹0
6₹34.90+₹655
4₹42.44+₹1,145
2₹58.66+₹2,200
1₹79.36+₹3,545
A few hours₹127.84+₹6,696

Most of the payoff arrives on the last day, so a butterfly opened a week out needs the index to stay near the middle strike for the whole week.

Moves away from the middle hurt less early on than at the end. With one day left, the model shows the butterfly at about +₹3,545 if Nifty is at 25,000, +₹2,349 at 24,850, +₹2,242 at 25,150 and close to its starting value at 24,700 or 25,300. On expiry day the same moves decide the whole trade.

Volatility

The butterfly is short volatility near the middle strike. A rise in IV makes the outer calls gain relative to the middle ones, which widens the value curve and lowers the butterfly's value. A fall in IV does the opposite. That is why many traders open butterflies after a volatile session when IV is high, and avoid them before scheduled events such as the RBI policy, the budget or a large company's results, when IV is likely to rise first.

Sizing a butterfly

Because the most a long butterfly can lose is its debit, sizing is simple: decide how much of the account you are willing to lose on one trade, and divide by the debit per lot. With a ₹5,00,000 account and a limit of 1% a trade, the budget is ₹5,000. At ₹1,613 per lot, that is three lots, risking ₹4,839.

Two cautions apply. First, the debit is only the loss at expiry; if you close early in a fast market, slippage on three strikes can add to it. Second, a butterfly loses more often than it wins, so runs of five or six losing weeks are normal in a backtest. Size so that such a run is a setback you can sit through, not one that forces you to stop. Use the quantity multiplier in the algo rather than separate copies, so one set of rupee targets and stops covers every lot.

What a butterfly costs to trade

A butterfly has three strikes and needs three orders to enter and three to exit, with the middle strike traded for two lots in one order. At ₹20 an order that is ₹120 of brokerage per round trip. On top come STT at 0.15% of the sell premium, exchange transaction charges, SEBI fees, stamp duty and GST.6

For the 200-point Nifty butterfly entered with 12 days left and closed with 2 days left and Nifty at 25,000, the total comes to about ₹269 per lot at the rates in force from 1 April 2026. Against a debit of ₹1,613 that is about 17%, and against the ₹2,200 profit in that scenario it takes about an eighth. Costs matter more for a butterfly than for most strategies because the debit is small. Two habits help: trade wider wings rather than many narrow ones, and let a losing butterfly expire worthless instead of paying to close legs that are worth almost nothing.

When a butterfly works, and when it does not

Works best when:

  • You expect a quiet expiry close to a known level.
  • IV is high and likely to fall.
  • Expiry is a few days away, so the payoff can build.

Struggles when:

  • The index trends away from the middle strike.
  • A large move happens on expiry day, the day the butterfly needs calm.
  • Bid-ask spreads are wide: three strikes in and out can cost a large share of a small debit.

Managing a butterfly

  • Take profits before the last minutes. Pinning the exact strike is rare. Many traders close at 30% to 50% of the maximum profit.
  • Accept the debit as the stop. The loss is limited, so many traders let a losing butterfly expire rather than pay to exit.
  • Shift if the view changes. Close and open a new butterfly centred at the new level.
  • Close before the last half hour on expiry day. The final minutes can swing the index across the whole profit range, and closing three legs in a fast market costs more.
  • Watch the short calls if the index rises sharply. A deep in-the-money short call can be exercised at expiry. The bought calls cover it, but settlement on all legs should be checked with your broker before you hold to the close.

Butterfly vs similar strategies

Long call butterflyIron flyShort straddle
Cash flowDebitCreditCredit
Maximum profitWidth minus debitThe creditThe premium
Maximum lossThe debitWidth minus creditUnlimited
MarginThe debitSPAN and exposure, reduced by the hedgeFull SPAN and exposure

A long call butterfly and an iron fly with the same strikes have almost the same payoff at expiry. The butterfly uses less margin because you pay for it upfront. The short straddle earns the most at the middle strike but has no limit to its loss.

The broken wing butterfly

In a broken wing butterfly, one wing is wider than the other: for example, buy the 24,800 call, sell two 25,000 calls and buy the 25,300 call. The wider upper wing makes the trade cheaper, and it can even be entered for a small credit, but it adds a loss above the top strike equal to the extra width less the credit. It turns a neutral butterfly into one that leans: it gains if Nifty stays at or below the middle strike and loses if Nifty rises far. QuantPower's templates include the Broken Wing Call Butterfly and Broken Wing Put Butterfly for this shape.

Building a butterfly as an algo in QuantPower

QuantPower runs the butterfly as an algo on your own broker account, through the two static IPs included with every account. You can draw the payoff first in the option strategy builder and use "Run as algo" to turn its legs into an algo, or start from the template. The steps below use the app's own screens.

  1. Open Algos → Option bots and load the Call Butterfly template (or Put Butterfly). The template is an open sample: once loaded, every leg and rule is yours to change.
  2. Set the legs as rule legs. A rule leg picks its strike fresh at each entry. Set the lower call to ITM 4 (four 50-point strikes below, 200 points), the two middle calls to ATM and the upper call to OTM 4, all on the weekly expiry. The strike can be counted from spot, from the future or from a synthetic future.
  3. Choose the entry. "At the time" enters all legs at a set time, such as 10:00 on the Friday before expiry. Set the days to the weekday you want.
  4. Leave the leg order to the algo. Buy legs go first and sell legs only after the buys are filled, so both wings are in place before the two middle calls are sold. On exit the short calls are bought back first.
  5. Set the exits for the whole algo. An M2M target in rupees, for example ₹2,500 per lot, and an M2M stop, for example the full debit. Add "Lock profit and trail" if you want to protect a gain once it reaches a level. Add an exit time, such as 14:45 on expiry day.
  6. Set the quantity multiplier if you trade more than one lot. Every leg and every rupee target scales with it.

If you want the butterfly to start only on a chart condition, such as India VIX above a level or Nifty inside a narrow range for the day, use a signal algo to start the option algo. A signal that places its own order costs no tokens; the option algo it starts is charged as a live algo.

A worked trade, start to finish

Here is how one trade runs on the algo described above, with model prices. On a Friday, four days before the Tuesday expiry, Nifty is at 25,010 and IV is 13%.

  1. Entry. The algo buys the 24,800 call at about ₹278.41 and the 25,200 call at about ₹67.16, then sells two 25,000 calls at about ₹150.06 each. The net debit is ₹45.44 per unit, ₹2,954 per lot. The maximum profit, at 25,000 on expiry, is ₹10,046 per lot.
  2. The rules. An M2M target of ₹2,500, an M2M stop of ₹2,954 (the debit) and an exit at 14:45 on Tuesday.
  3. Monday. Nifty closes the day at 24,980 with one trading day left. The butterfly is worth about ₹84.02 per unit and shows about +₹2,508 per lot. The target is reached. The algo buys back the two 25,000 calls first, then sells the two wings.
  4. Costs. Six orders and the statutory charges come to about ₹218 for the lot, leaving about ₹2,290.

The trade took about a quarter of the maximum. Holding into Tuesday could have paid more if Nifty stayed near 25,000, or given back most of the gain on a 200-point move. The target is a choice about that trade-off, made before the trade, not during it.

Testing before you go live

Run three tests, in this order:

  1. Backtest. QuantPower's option strategy backtest picks each leg's strike at the entry time, checks each leg's stop and target and the overall rupee stop and target every minute, closes at the exit time and deducts charges per leg. It holds back the last 30% of the days to check the rules on days they were not built on. See backtesting for the full method. A backtest costs 2 tokens, and the first 10 each week are free.
  2. Forward test. Switch the algo on in forward test. It runs on live prices with test money and no order reaches your broker. Forward test costs 100 tokens per algo per 28 days.
  3. Live, at the smallest size. Switch on Live with one lot. A live algo costs 200 tokens per 28 days, and orders inside it are unlimited.

Variables worth testing: the days to expiry at entry, the width (100, 200 or 300 points), the centring rule, the M2M target as a share of the maximum, and the exit time. A butterfly has many losing weeks and a few large winners, so judge it on the average result per trade after costs and on the longest run of losing weeks, not on the win rate.

Account safety above the algo

Every algo sits under the account's own controls:

  • Smart Exit sets a profit target, a stop-loss and a trailing step for the whole account. On a hit it stops the algos and squares off.
  • The daily loss limit refuses new orders once today's loss reaches it.
  • The kill switch stops trading in a segment until that segment's next session, and stops the algos running in it.

These cover every connected broker together. Set them before the first live day.

Common butterfly mistakes

  • Expecting the maximum. A pin on the exact middle strike is rare; plan around a share of it.
  • Entering too early. A butterfly three weeks from expiry barely moves while the index has time to drift away.
  • Narrow wings by habit. A 100-point butterfly is cheap because it rarely pays.
  • Paying to close worthless legs. Once the index is far outside the wings, the remaining value may be less than the cost of closing.
  • Ignoring costs. Six orders per round trip on a small debit add up quickly.
  • Holding through an event. A rise in IV and a large move both work against the trade.

Where the butterfly is going

Three changes shape how butterflies are traded in India. The first is the move to one weekly expiry per exchange, which concentrates butterfly trading on the Nifty Tuesday and Sensex Thursday expiries and on monthly Bank Nifty. The second is larger lot sizes, which raise the rupee value of the smallest butterfly and make wing width a more careful choice. The third is automation under the retail algo framework in force since 1 April 2026: a butterfly with fixed rules for entry day, strikes, target and exit time is the kind of strategy that runs as a registered algo through a broker.3 The trade itself stays the same: a small, known cost for a view on where the index will settle.

Start with 500 free tokens

Connect your broker, build a strategy and test it on paper before a single live order goes out.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it called a butterfly?

The payoff chart has a peak in the middle and two flat wings, like a butterfly's body and wings.

How often does a long butterfly end in profit?

Less often than it loses. In the model, a 200-point Nifty butterfly held to expiry finishes in profit about 22% of the time, and a 100-point one about 12%. The wins are larger than the losses, so the result over many trades depends on entry timing, exits and costs.

Is a put butterfly different from a call butterfly?

At the same three strikes and expiry, the two cost almost the same and have the same payoff at expiry. Choose the one with tighter quotes.

How much margin does a butterfly need?

Usually the net debit, because the bought calls cover the sold calls. Some brokers block more. Check before entry.

Can a butterfly be set up for a range rather than one level?

Yes. Use wider wings, or put two butterflies side by side at neighbouring middle strikes. Both widen the profit zone and raise the cost.

Can QuantPower run a butterfly every week on its own?

Yes. Load the Call Butterfly or Put Butterfly template in Option bots, set the legs as rule legs so the strikes are picked fresh at each entry, and choose the entry day and time. Once switched on, the algo enters and exits by its rules with no further tap.

References

  1. Fischer Black and Myron Scholes, "The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities", *Journal of Political Economy* 81(3), 637–654 (1973)
  2. Cboe Global Markets, history of the Chicago Board Options Exchange, opened 26 April 1973 (cboe.com)
  3. SEBI, circular on safer participation of retail investors in algorithmic trading, 4 February 2025, in force for every broker from 1 April 2026 (sebi.gov.in)
  4. SEBI, circular "Measures to strengthen Equity Index Derivatives framework for increased investor protection and market stability", 1 October 2024 (sebi.gov.in)
  5. NSE, circular on the revision of expiry days of derivatives contracts, effective 1 September 2025 (nseindia.com)
  6. Union Budget 2026-27: securities transaction tax on futures and options raised from 1 April 2026 (indiabudget.gov.in)
  7. Lawrence G. McMillan, *Options as a Strategic Investment* (first edition 1980)
  8. Sheldon Natenberg, *Option Volatility and Pricing* (first edition 1988; second edition 2015)
  9. NSE, equity derivatives contract specifications (nseindia.com)
The figures on this page are model estimates for illustration, not live prices. Options trading involves substantial risk. This guide is for education and is not investment advice.