The collar is the holder's answer to a risky period: a result, a policy decision, an election, a month in which a large gain could be lost. It does not try to profit from the event; it fixes the range of outcomes before the event happens. This guide explains how a collar works on an NSE stock and on Nifty futures, the numbers, how to choose the strikes and the month, what happens at expiry under physical settlement, how to manage and roll it, and how to set it up in QuantPower.
At a glance
| Collar | |
|---|---|
| Market view | You hold a position and want to limit the loss for a period |
| Legs | Hold the shares or futures, buy a put below, sell a call above |
| Cash flow | Close to zero: the call premium pays for most of the put |
| Maximum profit | Call strike minus purchase price, plus or minus the net premium |
| Maximum loss | Purchase price minus put strike, plus or minus the net premium |
| Time decay | Small effect, because the two options offset |
| Volatility | Small effect, for the same reason |
| Settlement | Stock options: physical. Index options: cash |
A short history of the collar
The collar grew out of two older strategies. Covered calls were written on US stocks before listed options existed, and once the Chicago Board Options Exchange began listing puts in 1977, a shareholder could also buy listed protection.2 Combining the two, a put bought with the money from a call sold, gave holders a way to protect a position without paying for it upfront. The Black–Scholes model of 1973 gave both legs a common price.1
In the 1990s the collar became a standard tool for executives and founders holding large blocks of their own company's shares, who wanted to protect their wealth without selling and triggering tax. Rules and disclosure requirements followed, because a collar can remove most of an insider's economic exposure while the shares stay in their name. Option textbooks such as Lawrence McMillan's set out the trade-off every collar makes: a floor bought with the large gains of strong months.7
In India, stock options began on the NSE in July 2001,3 and every stock option has been physically settled since October 2019.4 For a collar on shares, physical settlement means both legs can end with delivery: a put in the money at expiry sells your shares at the put strike, and a call in the money sells them at the call strike.
How a collar works
A protective put sets a floor but costs a premium every time you buy it. A covered call earns a premium but gives no floor. A collar combines them: the call you sell funds the put you buy.
The result is a position with a known range of outcomes until expiry:
- Below the put strike, the put gains as fast as the shares lose, so the loss stops.
- Between the strikes, the shares move freely and both options lose value.
- Above the call strike, the call loses as fast as the shares gain, so the gain stops.
It suits a holder who wants to protect a gain through a risky period without selling the shares, often because selling would end a long holding period or bring a tax bill forward. It suits less well a trader who wants the upside of a rally: the cap is the price of the floor.
The numbers on a stock
Take a hypothetical NSE stock at ₹1,400 with a lot size of 500 shares, 26 days to the monthly expiry, IV of 24% and an interest rate of 6.5%. Black–Scholes model prices:
- Hold 500 shares bought at ₹1,400
- Buy the 1,340 put at ₹11.36
- Sell the 1,460 call at ₹15.84
- Net credit: ₹4.48 a share, or ₹2,242
| Stock at expiry | Shares alone | Collar |
|---|---|---|
| ₹1,200 | −₹1,00,000 | −₹27,758 |
| ₹1,340 | −₹30,000 | −₹27,758 |
| ₹1,395.52 | −₹2,242 | breakeven |
| ₹1,400 | ₹0 | +₹2,242 |
| ₹1,460 | +₹30,000 | +₹32,242 |
| ₹1,550 | +₹75,000 | +₹32,242 |
The loss cannot exceed ₹27,758 and the gain cannot exceed ₹32,242, whatever the stock does before expiry. Buying the 1,340 put alone would cost about ₹5,679; the call pays for all of it and a little more.
Stock lot sizes are set by the exchange and revised from time to time, so check the current lot in the NSE contract specifications.8 One lot of options covers one lot of shares.
Choosing the strikes
The put strike sets how much you can lose. The call strike sets how much you can gain. Moving either one changes the cost:
| Put 1,340 / call 1,460 | Put 1,360 / call 1,460 | |
|---|---|---|
| Net premium | ₹2,242 credit | ₹465 debit |
| Maximum loss | ₹27,758 | ₹20,465 |
| Maximum gain | ₹32,242 | ₹29,535 |
A collar with equal premiums on both sides is called a zero-cost collar. In the model, a put about 60 points below the price and a call about 60 points above come close to zero cost; because puts usually trade at a higher implied volatility than calls the same distance away, a live zero-cost collar often needs the call a little closer to the price than the put.
Three ways to set the strikes:
- By the loss you can accept. Start from the floor: "I can lose 5% of this holding this month." Set the put there, then find the call that pays for it.
- By the price you would sell at. Start from the ceiling: "I would sell at ₹1,460 anyway." Set the call there, then buy the best put the premium allows.
- By delta. Many holders buy a put with a delta near −0.25 and sell a call with a delta near 0.25 to 0.30, which keeps the range similar as volatility changes.
Stock options usually have fewer liquid strikes than index options, so check the bid and ask on both legs before you enter. A wide spread on either leg can turn a zero-cost collar into a costly one.
Choosing the month
Stock options expire monthly. A collar for the current month protects through the next few weeks; a collar in the next month protects longer, at similar net cost but with strikes that sit further apart for the same premium. Match the month to the risk you are protecting against. If the risk is a result due in three weeks, the current month is enough, provided expiry comes after the result. If the risk is a slow decline over a quarter, a series of monthly collars, rolled each month, gives the protection without locking the range for too long.
A collar on Nifty futures
The same structure works on futures. With Nifty at 25,000 and 12 days to expiry (IV 14%), the fair futures price in the model is about 25,053:
- Buy one lot of Nifty futures at 25,053
- Buy the 24,700 put at ₹113.40
- Sell the 25,300 call at ₹150.11
- Net credit: ₹36.71 a unit
At expiry the loss is capped at about ₹20,559 per lot and the gain at about ₹18,441 per lot. Without the options, one lot of futures gains or loses ₹65 for every point. Index options settle in cash, so a futures collar ends with cash flows rather than delivery: at expiry the futures and both options settle at the final price.
A futures collar is mostly used by traders who hold a futures position for a view and want to carry it through an event, or by holders of an index portfolio who use Nifty options against it. Because index options settle in cash, a Nifty collar against a stock portfolio protects the portfolio only as far as the portfolio moves with Nifty.
What happens at expiry
Index options settle in cash. Stock options are physically settled: if the stock ends below the put strike, you deliver the shares at the put strike; if it ends above the call strike, you deliver them at the call strike. Between the strikes, both options expire worthless and you keep the shares. Close or roll the options before expiry if you want to keep the shares in every case.
STT on an option that is exercised is charged on the settlement value, at a higher rate than on the premium of an option you close, so letting an in-the-money leg settle costs more in tax than closing it the day before.6 Brokers also have their own rules for in-the-money stock options in the expiry week, including higher margins; check them before you carry a collar into the last days.
How a collar behaves before expiry
Before expiry, the floor already works but the ceiling is not yet reached. In the model, with 13 days left:
| Stock | Collar P&L per lot | Put | Call |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹1,280 | −₹26,667 | ₹62.22 | ₹0.04 |
| ₹1,340 | −₹16,831 | ₹22.67 | ₹0.81 |
| ₹1,460 | +₹18,518 | ₹0.62 | ₹28.07 |
| ₹1,520 | +₹27,435 | ₹0.04 | ₹69.66 |
On a fall, the put is worth at least its intrinsic value, so the loss is already close to, or less than, the ₹27,758 floor. On a rise, the call still has time value, so the gain before expiry is smaller than the ₹32,242 cap. The collar protects early and pays out its full upside only at expiry.
Because the position holds a long put and a short call, its Greeks largely offset. The shares carry a delta of 1; the put adds a negative delta and the call a negative delta, so the collar's delta at entry is below 1: in the example the put's delta is about −0.21 and the call's about 0.29, leaving the position with a delta of about 0.49. Time decay on the put is mostly paid for by the call's decay, and a rise in volatility raises both options together.
Margin, pledging and costs
The short call needs SPAN and exposure margin like any short option; the bought put needs only its premium. Shares you hold can be pledged as collateral after a haircut, but the clearing corporation requires at least half of the F&O margin in cash or cash equivalents. Some brokers recognise the shares and the put as cover and lower the margin; others treat the call as a separate short. Ask before you rely on the shares as margin.
At ₹20 brokerage an order and the rates in force from 1 April 2026, opening both legs of the stock collar for one lot costs about ₹65 in option charges, and closing both before expiry about the same again.6 On a position worth ₹7,00,000, option costs are small; the real cost of the collar is the capped upside.
Tax
The option legs are F&O transactions, generally treated as non-speculative business income. The shares follow capital gains rules, including when they are delivered against the put or the call at expiry: the delivery is a sale at the strike price, with short-term or long-term gains depending on how long you held them.5 Because the two sides fall under different heads, a gain on the put does not simply offset a capital loss on the shares. Check with a tax adviser for your own case.
When a collar works, and when it does not
Works best when:
- You hold a position with a gain you want to protect for a set period.
- An event is coming and you want a defined range of outcomes.
- IV is high enough that the call pays for most of the put.
Struggles when:
- The stock rallies far past the call strike: the cap costs the move.
- You collar every month without a reason. Over time, giving up the large gains can cost more than the protection saves.
- The stock has few liquid strikes, so both legs cost more than the model suggests.
Managing a collar
- Roll with the price. If the stock rises toward the call strike, close the collar and open a new one at higher strikes to lock in a higher floor.
- Remove it after the event. Close the options once the risk you were protecting against has passed. A collar left on by habit becomes a cap without a reason.
- Match the quantity. One lot of options covers one lot of shares or futures. A mismatch leaves part of the position unprotected or over-hedged.
- Decide on delivery in advance. If either leg is in the money in the expiry week, decide whether you will let the shares go or close the options.
A roll, in numbers
Suppose that six days before expiry the stock has risen to ₹1,455, close to the 1,460 call, and the holder wants to keep the shares and protect the higher price. In the model:
- The old 1,340 put is worth about ₹0.04 and the old 1,460 call about ₹16.21. Closing both costs about ₹8,085 for the lot, mostly to buy back the call.
- A new collar for the next month (34 days), with the 1,400 put at about ₹17.33 and the 1,520 call at about ₹21.01, brings in a net credit of about ₹1,841.
The roll costs about ₹6,244 in all, and in return the floor rises from ₹1,340 to ₹1,400 and the ceiling from ₹1,460 to ₹1,520. Whether that is worth paying depends on why the collar was there. If the event has passed, it may be better to remove the collar altogether and hold the shares unhedged.
Dividends and corporate actions
Shares under a collar keep their dividends and voting rights. A dividend lowers the share price on the ex-date, which raises the value of the put you hold and lowers the value of the call you sold, so a collar spanning a dividend tends to be a little cheaper to set up than the model suggests. For extraordinary dividends, bonus issues, splits and rights, the exchange adjusts the strike and lot of open contracts so that neither side gains from the action; after an adjustment, check that both legs still match the shares you hold.
Who a collar suits
A collar suits a holder of at least one lot of a stock with listed options who has a gain worth protecting, a clear period of risk, and a price at which he would sell anyway. It suits less well a holder who bought the stock for a large expected rise, because the call caps exactly that rise, or one whose holding is smaller than a lot. For a holder of an index portfolio, a Nifty collar protects as far as the portfolio follows the index; a portfolio of a few volatile stocks may not follow it closely, and the protection is weaker than the payoff table suggests.
Between the stock collar and the futures collar, the stock collar protects the actual shares and ends in delivery if a leg is in the money, while the futures collar ends in cash and protects a futures position or, loosely, an index portfolio. Choose the one that matches what you hold. For a holding spread across several stocks, a separate collar on each needs a lot of each and many orders; one Nifty collar is simpler and cheaper to run, at the cost of protecting only the part of the portfolio that moves with the index.
Collar vs other ways to protect a holding
| Collar | Protective put | Stop-loss order | Selling part of the holding | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Close to zero | The put premium | None | None |
| Floor through a gap | Yes | Yes | No: a gap can skip the stop | Partly |
| Upside kept | Up to the call strike | All of it, less the premium | All of it, until stopped | On the part kept |
| Tax event | Only if settled or closed | Only if settled or closed | A sale when triggered | A sale now |
A stop-loss order is free but can be skipped by a gap at the open. A put pays out whatever the price does, so the floor holds through a gap. The collar's cost is the capped upside; the protective put's cost is the premium.
Setting up a collar in QuantPower
A collar on shares combines a holding with options that last weeks, so in QuantPower it is set up with the trading screens rather than as an option algo. An algo with stock legs is intraday only, and an algo squares off at its exit time, so it does not suit a collar held for a month.
- Hold the shares in your broker account. Portfolio → Holdings shows them with profit and loss, and they can be pledged for margin there.
- Build the two option legs as a basket: buy the put and sell the call, same stock, same monthly expiry, one lot each, product Overnight. In a hedged basket, buy legs fill before sell legs, so the put is in place before the call is sold. The order sheet shows the margin before you send.
- Check the payoff first in the option strategy builder, with the shares included, to see the floor, the ceiling and the breakeven.
- Place GTT orders on the legs if you want them managed without watching, for example a GTT to buy back the call if its price falls to a few rupees, so the ceiling can be reset higher.
- Set an alert on the stock near each strike, so you are told in time to roll.
For a Nifty futures collar, the same basket holds the futures and both options. Quanty, the AI assistant in the app, can draw the payoff and check the plan, but it does not choose strikes for you: it is software, not an adviser.
Practising before you use real money
Every QuantPower account has a Forward test account with test money, kept apart from real Portfolio and Funds. Orders placed there fill at the price you see, so you can set up the two option legs of a collar as a basket in Forward test, watch how the put and the call move through a result or a volatile week, and close them, before doing the same on real shares. This is especially useful on stock options, where the bid-ask spread on the strikes you want may be wider than you expect.
What a collar does to a year
A single collar fixes one month's range. A collar renewed every month changes the shape of a whole year. In the example, each month's loss is held to about 4% of the holding and each month's gain to about 4.6%. A year of quiet months looks much the same with or without collars. A year with one sharp fall is much better with them. A year with one strong rally is much worse: the rally is cut into monthly slices, each capped. Over long periods, a strategy that sells the upside every month gives up the largest monthly gains, and for many stocks those few months carry much of the long-run return. That is the trade every collar makes, so use it for the months that carry a specific risk, not as a habit.
A worked example: protecting a gain through results
A holder bought 500 shares at ₹1,250 a year ago; they now trade at ₹1,400, a gain of ₹75,000. Results are due in two weeks and she does not want to sell. She sets up the collar from the example, 26 days to expiry:
- She buys the 1,340 put at ₹11.36 and sells the 1,460 call at ₹15.84, a net credit of about ₹2,242.
- Whatever the result, at expiry her shares are worth at least ₹1,340 and at most ₹1,460 a share, so her gain since purchase stays between about ₹47,242 and ₹1,07,242, including the credit.
- The result is weak and the stock opens at ₹1,280. Her shares have lost ₹60,000 on the day, but the put is now worth at least ₹60 a share, about ₹30,000 for the lot, and the call is nearly worthless.
- After the result she closes both options, keeping the shares with their reduced price and the gain on the put.
Had the result been strong and the stock opened at ₹1,520, she would have faced the other choice: let the shares go at ₹1,460, or buy back the call at a loss to keep them.
Common collar mistakes
- Using the collar as a standing hedge. Over many months, the capped gains usually cost more than the floors save.
- Mismatching quantities. Options cover one lot each; the holding may not be a whole number of lots.
- Ignoring liquidity. Wide bid-ask spreads on stock options can make a zero-cost collar costly.
- Forgetting delivery. An in-the-money leg at expiry sells the shares.
- Leaving the call short after selling the shares. If you sell the shares, close the call first, or it becomes a naked short call.
- Choosing the call for its premium alone. A call that pays for the whole put but sits just above the price caps almost every gain; set the ceiling where you would genuinely be content to sell.
Where the collar is going
The collar has moved from a tool of large shareholders to one any holder of a lot of shares can use. In India, physical settlement since 2019 made the collar complete: the floor and the ceiling now both end in delivery, not just cash. Larger lot sizes and higher STT from 1 April 2026 raise the stake of each collar, which favours using it for a defined risk rather than every month. As trading apps put holdings, option chains, baskets and GTT orders on one screen, setting up a collar becomes a few minutes' work; deciding whether the event is worth capping the upside for remains the holder's own judgement.
Start with 500 free tokens
Connect your broker, build a strategy and test it on paper before a single live order goes out.
Frequently asked questions
What is a zero-cost collar?
A collar where the premium from the call you sell equals the premium of the put you buy, so the protection costs nothing upfront.
Is a collar better than a stop loss?
A stop loss can be skipped by a gap at the open. A put pays out whatever the price does, so the floor holds even through a gap. The collar's cost is the capped upside.
Can I collar Nifty?
Yes, with Nifty futures, or with options against an index portfolio. See the futures example above.
What is the difference between a collar and a protective put?
A protective put buys protection outright. A collar also sells a call to pay for it, which caps the gain.
How long should a collar stay on?
For the period of the risk it protects against, such as until a result is out, then remove it. A collar left on every month caps every strong month.
Does a collar need much margin?
The bought put needs only its premium. The sold call needs SPAN and exposure margin, which some brokers reduce when the shares are held or pledged as cover. Ask your broker how it treats a call written against shares.
Can a QuantPower algo run a collar?
Not as a single algo, because an algo with stock legs is intraday. Hold the shares and set the two option legs as a hedged basket, with GTT orders and alerts to manage them.
Related guides
- Options risk management
- Hedging meaning
- Options profit calculator: draw the collar's payoff
References
- Fischer Black and Myron Scholes, "The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities", *Journal of Political Economy* 81(3), 637–654 (1973)
- Cboe Global Markets, history of the Chicago Board Options Exchange, opened 26 April 1973, puts listed from 1977 (cboe.com)
- NSE, introduction of options on individual securities, July 2001 (nseindia.com)
- SEBI, circular on physical settlement of stock derivatives, April 2018, extended to all stock derivatives from October 2019 (sebi.gov.in)
- Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024: capital gains rates on listed shares from 23 July 2024 (incometaxindia.gov.in)
- Union Budget 2026-27: securities transaction tax on futures and options raised from 1 April 2026 (indiabudget.gov.in)
- Lawrence G. McMillan, *Options as a Strategic Investment* (first edition 1980)
- NSE, equity derivatives contract specifications (nseindia.com)